A visitor following one sign should be able to trust the next.
But at heritage sites, signage is often added to or adapted over many years. Routes change, information becomes outdated and individual signs begin to look different from one another. Eventually, what was once a useful wayfinding scheme can become difficult to follow.
The temptation may be to replace the signs that look tired or damaged. Yet before making any changes, it is worth asking a wider question. How well is the existing signage working for the people who use it?
That is where a heritage signage audit becomes valuable.
A good starting point is to walk through the site from a visitor’s perspective. Can signs be seen clearly from the direction people approach them? Are routes easy to follow? Is the information accurate, and does it remain consistent from one location to the next?
Over time, different styles of signage may have been introduced across an estate, cathedral or historic building. Materials, colours and terminology can vary, sometimes leaving visitors with information that feels disconnected.
Maps should be considered as part of this review too. Good wayfinding map design relies on accurate information and clear routes. If a map shows one route while nearby signs suggest another, visitors are left to work it out for themselves.
A consistent signage scheme helps people move through a site with confidence, without having to question the information in front of them.
Our work at Rochester Cathedral provides a good example of why looking at the wider scheme matters.
The Cathedral’s existing external signage had become inconsistent, with different materials and formats introduced across the site. Changeable information, including opening hours, had also been incorporated directly into the signs, making updates difficult and affecting their appearance over time.
Working alongside Olley Design, we manufactured and installed a new external wayfinding scheme that brought greater consistency to the site. The new scheme simplified information, made directions clearer and improved guidance for wheelchair and buggy access routes.
The project shows how replacing outdated signage can be an opportunity to improve the wider visitor experience, rather than simply update the appearance of individual signs.

Of course, not every sign identified during an audit will need replacing.
A weathered timber sign may still be structurally sound, while a damaged panel or outdated graphic might be replaced without disturbing the original structure. As we explore in our article on repairing, refurbishing or replacing outdoor signage, retaining serviceable components can help extend the life of existing signage and avoid unnecessary waste.
It is also worth considering how the signage will be maintained in the years ahead. If opening times, visitor information or routes are likely to change, designing signs with replaceable panels or components can make future updates much more straightforward.
Some signs may need replacing, while others might benefit from repair, repositioning or removal. What matters is making considered decisions that improve the visitor experience while respecting the character of the site.
If you’re reviewing the signage at a heritage site, our team can help you understand what is working and where improvements may be needed. Get in touch to discuss your existing scheme.